Jun 30, 2008

Politics of climate change legislation

Here is an inside view of how the recent Lieberman-Warner climate change bill was debated in the Senate. It is funny (and sad) how some senators talk of cap & trade as a carbon tax. The notion that one can generate revenues and jobs by a cap & trade system completely intrigues me. Meanwhile the Chicago Climate Exchange already has a voluntary trading system for carbon. When is the best time to take action against global warming? NOW. As Senator Boxer points out, waiting to legislate until the gas price comes down will be a fatal mistake.


Resource Conservation & Game Theory

Jeffrey Sachs seems to think that a cooperative approach on the world's most pressing problems of energy, water, raw materials will eventually help in sustaining high growth rates. I like his argument that the world economy has never been so large. This, he says necessitates greater conservation because free market economics which dictate that the prices be set by supply and demand will result in price spikes when disurption of supply/supply concerns set in. As an example, the above figure (credit: Yahoo Finance) shows how the NASDAQ and S&P 500 indices fell as the commodity prices rose in Feb'08. Back then (as it is now), concerns over global food production (mainly corn, rice) and the everincreasing oil prices led to the commodity price increases that we see today.

With my limited knowledge of economics, I think that Prof. Sachs's approach parallels John Nash's game theory. The most optimal distribution of resources (and the best global output) will occur when all the players (individual nations) coordinate their act and come together. However, in practice, every nation has its own strategic objectives which leads to lesser cooperation in sharing/developing the world's resources.

My views:
Conserving resources to save growth sounds like a noble idea. However, will India, China and the rest of the developing world wait until mutual understanding of resource use happen? The recently released Indian climate change plan emphasizes solar energy and sustainability. Given that most assessments of long term energy use have fossil fuels still being the major source of energy, it remains to be seen how far the present Indian government (and its successors) will go towards making climate action a reality.


Jun 1, 2008

Save the planet by driving a hummer?

NPR has interesting interview with Spencer Reiss on how consumer choices may effect global greenhouse gas concentrations. Find the link here . One central theme that recurs in the discussion is the concept of system-wide analyses to determine whether something is good for the environment or not. This is also what life cycle analyses (LCA) does.


The Energy Webring